Washington Medical Organizations Support Pause on Implementation of I-638

The Washington State Medical Association along with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists – Washington Section, the Washington Academy of Family Physicians, the Washington Academy of Physician Associates, the Washington Chapter of the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Washington Chapter of the American College of Physicians, and the Washington State Psychiatric Association announce their support for the lawsuit brought by American Civil Liberties Union of Washington, Legal Voice, and the Washington Education Association seeking to pause implementation of Initiative 638. While we recognize the public’s concern for fairness in sports, as statewide medical organizations we are deeply troubled by the initiative’s mandate imposing medically unnecessary examinations and verification requirements on girls participating in school sports.

I-638, scheduled to go into effect on Dec. 3, seeks to prohibit transgender girls from competing in girls’ K-12 interscholastic sports and requires “biological sex” verification of all female athletes. Without more time to develop statewide guidance, physicians and other clinicians face difficult professional and ethical questions about how to comply with the initiative’s requirements while maintaining accepted standards of care. Implementing these requirements in the middle of the school year as students prepare for winter sports creates unnecessary challenges for students, families, schools, and the overall healthcare system.

The text of I-638 outlines that girls seeking to participate in school sports must “provide a health examination and consent form or other statement signed by the student’s personal health care provider that verifies the student’s biological sex, relying only on one or more of the following: The student’s reproductive anatomy, genetic makeup, or normal endogenously produced testosterone levels.”

The initiative, however, does not clearly define what constitutes a health examination nor does it identify what physicians must do to comply with the verification requirement options. For example, it is unclear whether physicians would be required to conduct examinations of girls’ “reproductive anatomy.” Such exams are not part of today’s routine sports physicals and are not medically necessary to determine whether a child can safely participate in athletics.

Sports physicals, or preparticipation physician evaluations, are designed to diagnose conditions that could put a child or young athlete at risk of serious injury, illness, or other health complications during sports participation. The current versions of the model forms are written by the American Academy of Pediatrics with the American Academy of Family Physicians, the American College of Sports Medicine, the American Medical Society for Sports Medicine, the American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine, and the American Osteopathic Academy of Sports Medicine. The evaluations follow established medical standards and focus on a child’s health history and physical well-being. They do not routinely include examinations of a child’s genitals or “reproductive anatomy.” Such examinations are only performed when medically indicated.

Requiring physicians to verify “biological sex” for sports participation represents a significant departure from accepted medical practice and raises serious ethical and privacy concerns. The lack of clarity and use of generalized terms such as “reproductive anatomy” that lack clinical specificity put physicians in an untenable position. An exam to verify “reproductive anatomy” could be external and internal.

Even the possibility of an unnecessary genital examination could cause significant worry, anxiety, and fear in our female patients. Some girls may decide not to participate in sports. Given the well-established health and developmental benefits of sports participation for children and adolescents, creating additional barriers that discourage girls from playing sports is a serious concern.

Access to healthcare is another important consideration. According to the 2023-24 National Survey of Children’s Health, an estimated 25% of Washington children (413,000) do not have a personal clinician. Many school districts offer free sports physicals at schools, making participation more accessible for children who may not have an established primary care physician. I-638 does not address how these physicals, often conducted in school settings and other public spaces, would be handled. Without clear guidance and the necessary privacy and equipment, physicians may stop coordinating with such programs. Not having access to such a program will cause a huge barrier to sports participation.

Requiring a separate examination or specialized testing could create additional costs, delays, and access barriers, particularly for families with limited financial resources. The initiative’s three verification requirements, examination of “reproductive anatomy,” testing of testosterone levels, or genetic testing, raise concerns about unequal access. Families who can afford laboratory testing may choose that option to avoid a genital examination for their child. These tests can be expensive, and because they are not medically necessary, are not likely to be covered by insurance. The cost of such testing could disproportionately affect girls from families with lower income.

Verifying genetic makeup could involve chromosome testing through a blood draw. Assessing testosterone levels could require additional testing and medical history (such specific hormonal assessment to determine gender classification in sports is opposed by the American Medical Association). None of these procedures is routinely necessary for a standard sports physical. Ordering such tests to solely satisfy an athletic eligibility requirement raises significant ethical, privacy, and cost concerns.

Physicians have a professional and ethical responsibility to recommend and perform examinations and tests based on medical necessity. Conducting procedures that are not medically indicated can undermine the physician-patient relationship and compromise patient trust.

I-638 also creates considerable uncertainty for physicians who may be asked to verify and document a student’s “biological sex” for participation in school sports. Questions remain about appropriate clinical standards for verification, the use of medical or genetic testing, informed consent, patient privacy and confidentiality, and the handling of students with differences in sex development. These concerns are heightened because the initiative introduces verification responsibilities that are not part of the routine sports physicals or the standard clinical practice, potentially placing clinicians in the position of making determinations without clearly established clinical guidelines or protections.

Every child deserves a sports physical that respects their health, their privacy, and follows accepted medical practice. No girl should have to undergo a medically unnecessary examination of her “reproductive anatomy” to participate in school sports.

The WSMA and supporting organizations support the request for a preliminary injunction to pause implementation of I-638 while these significant medical, ethical, and practical concerns are addressed and will be moving forward with filing a formal amicus brief in support of the preliminary injunction.